Yana Malik All articles
Personal

Four Rules, One Sore Spot: The Comments I Delete and the Ones I Let Sit

Yana Malik
Four Rules, One Sore Spot: The Comments I Delete and the Ones I Let Sit

Photo: Lucas Werkmeister, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

I used to think of moderation as a mood. If I was having a good day, I left everything up. If I was having a bad day, I deleted anything that looked at me weird. That is not a system. That is a person with a phone and too much power.

Now I have rules. Four of them. My team uses them too, which means the comment section does not depend on whether I slept well. It depends on whether a comment passes the test.

Here is the honest version, including the one comment I still think about deleting.

Rule One: Is It Aimed at a Person or an Idea?

This is the first cut. If a comment is arguing with an idea, a song, a outfit, a decision, a take — it stays. If it is aimed at a person's body, family, safety, or right to exist, it goes.

That sounds obvious. It is not. People are very good at dressing up a personal attack as a critique. 'I just think your content has gotten lazy' is a critique. 'You look like you smell' is not. One is about the work. One is about the person. I do not need to litigate the difference in public.

We remove slurs, threats, doxxing, and anything that shares private information. We do not remove 'I did not like this song.' We do not remove 'this take is wrong.' We do not remove 'I miss the old you.' That last one is not a compliment, but it is not a violation either.

Rule Two: Does It Make the Room Smaller?

I stole this from a friend who runs a community space. She asks, 'Does this make the room bigger or smaller?' A comment that makes the room bigger invites people in. A comment that makes the room smaller tells people to leave.

'Here is why I disagree' makes the room bigger. 'Nobody wants you here' makes it smaller. 'I had a different experience' makes it bigger. 'You are exactly what is wrong with people like you' makes it smaller.

This rule is not about tone policing. You can be angry and still make the room bigger. You can be calm and still make it smaller. The question is whether the comment is opening a door or closing one.

Rule Three: Is It a Question or a Performance?

Some comments are real questions. 'What camera do you use?' 'How did you get into this?' 'Do you have a link to the charity you mentioned?' Those get replies, or someone on my team replies.

Some comments are performances. They are not looking for an answer. They are looking for an audience. 'Why do you never talk about [thing you talk about constantly]?' is a performance. 'You have changed' is a performance. 'I bet you will not answer this' is a performance.

We leave performances up unless they break another rule. We just do not feed them. There is a difference between censorship and not handing someone a microphone.

Rule Four: Is This Mine to Answer?

This is the one that saves me the most energy. Not every comment is mine to answer. Some are about my work. Some are about my body. Some are about my family. Some are about a decision I made five years ago that I have already explained twice.

If it is about the work, I try to answer. If it is about my body, my family, or my safety, it gets removed or ignored. If it is a question I have answered in a pinned post, a highlight, or a podcast, I let the archive do the work.

This is not me being above it. This is me being a person with a finite amount of attention and a team that deserves clear instructions.

The One I Still Think About

There was a comment that said, 'You have changed and I do not recognize you anymore.' It was not mean. It was not a slur. It did not threaten me. It just sat there under a photo of me at a dinner with friends, and it made my stomach drop.

I thought about deleting it. I had my thumb on it. Then I thought about Rule Two. Did it make the room smaller? Not really. It was a person saying they missed something. That is not a crime. That is a relationship changing in public.

So I left it. I did not reply. I did not like it. I did not pin it. I just let it be a comment on the internet, which is what it is.

Do I still think about deleting it? Yes. Every time I see it. But I do not because the comment section is not a highlight reel. It is a room. And rooms have people in them who are disappointed, confused, and not always kind. My job is not to make everyone happy. My job is to make the room safe enough that people can be honest without being cruel.

What This Looks Like in Practice

I am not asking for a comment section that only claps. I am asking for one where people can disagree without trying to dismantle each other. That requires rules. It requires consistency. It requires a team that knows what we stand for, not just what we are in the mood for.

So if your comment gets deleted, it is not because I am fragile. It is because it broke a rule. And if it stays? It is because I decided the room could hold it.

All Articles

Related Articles

One Closed Door, Six Years of Dominoes: How a Rejection Built This Life

One Closed Door, Six Years of Dominoes: How a Rejection Built This Life

The 3 AM Voice Notes and the Handwritten Letters: How I Actually Read Your Messages

The 3 AM Voice Notes and the Handwritten Letters: How I Actually Read Your Messages

The Real Headliners: Ode to the Crew Who Never Take a Bow

The Real Headliners: Ode to the Crew Who Never Take a Bow